The Good Thief Dilemma:

A memoir, a meditation, an investigation into the mysteries of spiritual abuse

  • Please visit this Overview (not pay walled)

    You can join this project at anytime.

    Please respect the copyrighted nature of this content, and don’t share anything behind a paywall other than to excerpt it or recommend it.

    This is a content warning for the project in its entirety as this unfolding text is a frank exploration of varied forms and manifestations of abuse, sociopathic behavior, and moral injury.

  • After purchasing access to this content, a preview of each post will be emailed to you.

    To read the full post online here at the website you will need to login to this site (login is in the upper right corner)

    A one time fee gives you full access to the unfolding project as it is posted.

The Good Thief Dilemma
$15.00
One time

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Read from the bottom up

Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Chapter Ten: Family Tree

Each new bit, each tantalizing piece of information sent an electric charge through me, consuming me, preoccupying me, shorting out all my circuits until the information suddenly “clicked” into or out place. Some pieces snapped together. Some beliefs were pulled apart. 

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Reverie #9: Nature

It had never entered my head that what I was writing had any connection with art… C. G. Jung

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Reverie 8: Sister-Mothers

The image of the baby swallowed up in the muddy water repeats. What disturbs me the most is the subtle thrill, the relief, that is entangled with the horror of the image of a drowning infant. I walk hunched over, skulking back up the pier hoping that no one saw me drop the baby.

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Chapter Eight: The Battle and the War

“If in the first act you have hung a pistol on the wall, then in the following one it should be fired. Otherwise don't put it there.” ~ Chekhov

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Reverie 7: Mother Ring

But my Mother-complex was thankfully formed from the love and courage of many mothers – a long line of them – not only my mother and my step-mother – and I suspect this tap root from my family reached into a deep underground spring of clear water, and that it traveled through many rings, many generations and sustained me when there was little in the surface environment that could.

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Chapter Seven: A Mother Instead

So here I am,  - I keep showing up at this church, while I’m trying to sort what happened to my family, realizing how little I knew about Father’s life before or after the seven years of chaos he inflicted on our household.  I can go back into a traditional church because by now  the intense “post-traumatic/spiritual abuse” emotional charge has been drained enough for me to discern what I may have cherished there, what I lost, what I still yearned for, what I might need, what I reject, what has died, and what is entirely uninteresting to me. 

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Chapter Six: In The Attic

March 16,  1979

I made the auditions for Cat on a Hot Tin Roof. I am a no-necked monster.

Mom is getting married Sunday.

Band Festival is tomorrow, I gotta get up at 7:30 am. Oh well.

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

reverie 5: Rashōmon

I’d grown up in a Rashomon tale – where facts and motivations were constantly shifting to shore up each adult’s idealized self, and erase all of their failure and culpability, and none of their stories fit together.

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Chapter Five: Confirmation

All memory is false memory, and all memory is fiction, but memory can be confirmed and questions can be both asked and answered. 

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

REVERIE 4: Return Pain

Nostalgia for one's childhood does not necessarily mean that the childhood was a happy one.

~ Observer 8 February 7/5/1959   - from the Oxford English Dictionary

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Chapter Four: Particularly The Tongue

The binding is of the whole body but particularly the tongue…

The search is for lost narrative, for discarded memory, for those things that we might have considered worthless”

~ Barbara Glasson, A Spirituality of Surviva

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Reverie 3: Somebody’s Daughter

A strange parthenogenesis – not quite a like a great black snake who creates her own offspring without a reproductive partner. But also not a father-Zeus who generates a daughter on his own and pulls her out of his own head.

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Chapter Three: Possession

Father said he was an exorcist. He told stories about a poltergeist that haunted his seminary dorm.

None of these ghost stories scared me. The only thing that terrified me was Satan himself.

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Reverie 2 : Like a Dream

I want emptiness, open space, unexplained and inferred things, disjointed time. I want it to be like a dream. To go in and out of past and present, personal and professional. Like a dream does

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Reverie 1: Safe House

“Remember Lot’s wife: those who try to make their lives secure will lose it, and those who lose their life will keep it.” Luke 17:32

Read More
Martha Crawford Martha Crawford

Chapter One: In The Basement

Ellie was gone. But not questions she had opened up that night. They were still swirling in my head in the moments when the waves of grief for her, for my mother, let up. “Unnie, you know what he was doing in the back basement don’t you?

Read More